Russian Journal of Theriology. Main page    

Russian Journal of Theriology. Main page
Free access to the published articles
Information about online submission, Articles format, Instructions for authors etc
Instructions for reviewers
Subscription and prices
Contacts

Русскоязычный вариант сайта
Species composition, abundance and spatial structure of bat community hibernating in Tanechkina and Staroladozhskaya Caves, Leningrad Region, Russia
Matlova M.A., Agafonova E.V., Guseva N.V., Chistyakov D.V.
P. 01-17
The paper presents the results of studies of bats hibernating in the Staroladozhskaya and Tanechkina caves in Leningrad Region, Russia. Species composition, abundance, peculiarities of bats’ spatial distribution, and microclimatic conditions in the caves were studied in 2003 and 2018–2022. Six species of bats were recorded: Myotis daubentonii, M. dasycneme, M. brandtii/mystacinus, M. nattereri, Plecotus auritus, and Eptesicus nilssonii. The most significant species diversity and abundance of bats were noted in the Tanechkina Cave, which is one of the longest in Leningrad Region. The number of hibernating bats has increased nearly fivefold since 2003, with circa 1900–2500 bats utilizing the cave presently. The composition of species abundance has changed over the years. In 2003, M. daubentonii and M. dasycneme predominated by number; whereas at the present, M. dasycneme comprises more than 70% of the total number of bats. The data on changes in the spatial structure of one of the largest bat communities in Leningrad Region over the period of ten years are presented in our paper for the first time.

DOI: 10.15298/rusjtheriol.23.1.01

References

  • Agafonova E.V., Matlova M.A., Viskontene A.L., Guseva N.V. & Natalyin N.A. 2022. [Natterer’s bat (Myotis nattereri) on hibernation in the caves of the Leningrad Region in 2019–2021] // [Mammals in the changing world: actual problems of theriology. Proceedings of XI Congress of the Theriological Society of the Russian Academy of Sciences. March 14–18, 2022, Moscow, IEE RAS]. Moscow: KMK Scientific Press. P.7 [in Russian].
  • Agapov I.A. 2012. Natural caves of the North-West of Russia. The use of caves in human culture // Proceedings of the 13th National Congress of Speleology. 29th Sept.–1st Okt. 2012. P.6–9.
  • Agapov I.A., Lyakhnitsky Y.S. & Hlebalin I.U. 2013. The man-made underground cavities of North-West Russia // Proceedings of the 16th International Congress of Speleology, Czech Republic, Brno, July 21–28, 2013. Vol.2. P.179–184.
  • Bachorec E., Bartonicka T., Heger T., Pikula J. & Zukal J. 2021. Cold arousal — a mechanism used by hibernating bats to reduce the energetic costs of disturbance // Journal of Thermal Biology. Vol.101. P.103–107.
  • Baagøe H.J. & Degn H.J. 2009. The bats in Daugbjerg and Mønsted Kalkgruber in the outflow period 2009. Prepared for the Danish Forest and Nature Agency. Central Jutland. 38 p.
  • Baranauskas K. 2006a. Bat species composition and abundance in two underground hibernaculae in Vilnus before and after fencing // Ekologija. No.1. P.10–15.
  • Baranauskas K. 2006b. New data on bats hibernating in underground sites in Vilnus, Lithuania // Acta Zoologica Lituanica. Vol.16. No.2. P.102–106.
  • Belkin V.V., Yakimova A.E., Panchenko D.V. & Tirronen K.F. 2013. [Bats (Chiroptera) at winter sites in Karelia Republic] // [Proceedings of the Samara Scientific Center of the Russian Academy of Science]. Vol.15. No.3. P.1080–1083 [in Russian].
  • Belkin V.V., Panchenko D.V., Tirronen K.F., Yakimova A.E. & Fedorov F.V. 2015. [Ecological status of bats (Chiroptera) in winter roosts in eastern Fennoscandia] // Ecologiya. No.5. P.374–380 [in Russian].
  • Belkin V.V., Ilyukha V.A., Khizhkin E.A., Yakimova A.E. & Morozov A.V. 2019. [Underground fortification structures in the middle and northern taiga subzones as places of bats wintering] // [Speleology and spelestology: proceedings of the X International Scientific Conference]. Naberezhnye Chelny NCSPU. P.279–284 [in Russian].
  • Belkin V.V., Fyodorov F.V., Ilyukha V.A. & Yakimova A.E. 2021. Characteristics of the bat (Chiroptera) population in protected areas in the northern and middle taiga subzones of European Russia // Nature Conservation Research. Vol.6. Suppl.1. P.17–31.
  • Bernard R., Jaros R., Samolag J. & Kosicki J.Z. 2019. Long-term monitoring of a winter bat assemblage revealed large fluctuations and trends in species abundance // European Journal of Ecology. Vol.5. No.2. P.72–78.
  • Bogdarina S.V. & Strelkov P.P. 2003. [Distribution of bats (Chiroptera) in the north of Europeen Russia] // Plecotus et al. No.6. P.7–28 [in Russian, with English summary].
  • Bol’shakov V.N., Orlov O.L. & Snit’ko V.P. 2005. [Bats of Urals] Yekaterinburg: Akademkniga. 176 p. [in Russian].
  • Bondarenko A.M. 2005. [The spatial distribution and number of serotine bats Eptesicus serotinus (Schreber, 1774) in mines of village Bychok (Moldova, Transdniester Region)] // Plecotus et al. No.8. P.3–7 [in Russian, with English summary].
  • Boyles J.G., Johnson J.S., Blomberg A. & Lilley T.M. 2019. Optimal hibernation theory // Mammal Review. Vol.50. No.1. P.91–100.
  • Chistyakov D.V. 1999. [Assessment of the current state of wintering bats (Chiroptera, Vespertilionidae) of the Leningrad Region] // Bulletin of St. Petersburg State University. Biological Series. No.1. P.41–47 [in Russian].
  • Chistyakov D.V. 2001. Present state of the bat community hibernating in artificial caves near St. Petersburg // Proc. of the VIIIth EBRS. No.2. P.41–45.
  • Chistyakov D.V. 2009. [New data on bats hibernating in artificial underground constructions in Leningrad Region] // Plecotus et al. No.11–12. P.14–17 [in Russian, with English summary].
  • Chistyakov D.V. & Bogdarina S.V. 2010. [New findings of hibernating bats (Chiroptera, Vespertilionidae) in the north-west of Russia] // Bulletin of St. Petersburg State University. Vol.3. No.3. P.3–8 [in Russian].
  • Chistyakov D.V. & Nikulin A.D. 2010. [The influence of the anthropogenic factor on the wintering conditions of bats in the Leningrad Region] // [Proceedings of the international scientific-practical conference “Speleology and spelestology: development and interaction of the sciences”], November, 16–20, Naberezhnye Chelny. P.320–322 [in Russian].
  • Ciechanowski M., Sachanowicz K. & Kokurewicz T. 2007. Rare or underestimated? The distribution and abundance of the pond bat (Myotis dasycneme) in Poland // Lutra. Vol.50. No.2. P.107–134.
  • Doty A.C., Currie S.E., Stawski C. & Geiser F. 2018. Can bats sense smoke during deep torpor? // Physiology and Behavior. Vol.185. P.31–38.
  • Dzieciolowski R., Wojtaszyn G., Laskowska-Dzieciolowska K., Stephan W., Rutkowski T. & Lesinski G. 2022. Changes in bat abundance in winter roosts close to the Polish-German border in the years 2000–2019: are the increasing trends continued in Central Europe? // Acta Zoologica Bulgarica. Vol.74. No.2. P.227–233.
  • Fleming T.H. 2018. Bat migration // Encyclopedia of Animal Behavior. P.605–610.
  • Fritze M. & Puechmaille S. 2018. Identifying unusual mortality events in bats: a baseline for bat hibernation monitoring and white-nose syndrome research // Mammal Review. Vol.48. No.3. P.224–228.
  • Grzywinski W., Boratynski J.S., Gorecki J., Jaros R., Ignaczak M., Karwowska B., Kmiecik A., Kmiecik P., Lochynski M., Malak K., Polowy K., Wieczorec M. & Wojtaszyn G. 2012. Bats hibernating in stand-alone bunkers of the Miedzyrzecki Fortified Front in the years 2005–2012 // Vespertilio. Vol.16. P.149–157.
  • Hope P.R., Bohmann K., Gilbert M.T.P., Zepeda-Mendoza M.L., Razgour O. & Jones G. 2014. Second generation sequencing and morphological faecal analysis reveal unexpected foraging behaviour by Myotis nattereri (Chiroptera, Vespertilionidae) in winter // Frontiers in Zoology. Vol.11. P.e39.
  • Hutson T., Aulagnier S. & Nagy Z. 2007. Myotis dasycneme (Europe assessment) // The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2007. Accessed on 10 November 2023. P.e.T14127A4400393.
  • Kervyn T., Lamotte S., Nyssen P. & Verschuren J. 2009. Major decline of bat abundance and diversity during the last 50 years in southern Belgium // Belgium Journal of Zoology. Vol.139. No.2. P.124–132.
  • Kovalyov D.N. 2017. Hibernacula of Myotis bats in artificial caves in the Leningrad Region // Russian Journal of Theriology. Vol.16. No.1. P.94–109.
  • Kovalyov D.N. & Popov I.Yu. 2011. [Annual cycle of the pond bat (Myotis dasycneme) spatial distribution and abundance in Saint-Petersburg and Leningrad Region] // Transactions of the Karelian Research Centre RAS. Biogeography Series. Vol.11. No.1. P.68–82 [in Russian].
  • Kovalyov D.N., Popov I.Yu. & Schekhovsky E.A. 2014. [The differences in species composition of bats on the wintering of Leningrad Region, depending on the location and microclimate of underground shelters] // Vlasov D.Yu. (ed.). Proceedings of the IX International ecological School conference in the manor “Sergiyevka” — a monument of natural and cultural heritage: “Preservation of environment and optimization of her use in the Baltic region”. St. Petersburg: VVM. P.230–235 [in Russian].
  • Lesinski G., Kowalski M., Domanski J., Dzieciolowski R., Laskowska-Dzieciolowska K. & Dziegielewska M. 2004. The importance of small cellars to bat hibernation in Poland // Mammalia. Vol.68. No.4. P.345–352.
  • Luo J., Jiang T., Lu G., Wang L. & Feng J. 2013. Bat conservation in China: should protection of subterranean habitats be a priority? // Oryx. Vol.47. No.4. P.526–531.
  • Lutsar L., Masing M. & Poots L. 2000. Changes in the number of hibernating bats in the caves of Piusa (Estonia), 1949–1999 // Folia Theriologica Estonica. No.5. P.101–117.
  • Martinkova N., Baird S.J.E., Kana V. & Zima J. 2020. Bat population recoveries give insight into clustering strategies during hibernation // Frontiers in Zoology. Vol.17. No.1. P.1–11.
  • Masing M., Poots L., Randla T. & Lutsar L. 1999. 50 years of bat-ringing in Estonia: methods and the main results // Plecotus et al. No.2. P.20–35.
  • Masing M. & Lutsar L. 2007. Hibernation temperatures in seven species of sedentary bats (Chiroptera) in northeastern Europe // Acta Zoologica Lituanica. Vol.17. No.1. P.47–55.
  • Masing M., Baranauskas K., Siivonen Y. & Wermundsen T. 2009. Bats hibernating in Kaunas Fortress, Lithuania // Estonian Journal of Ecology. Vol.58. No.3. P.192–204.
  • Matlova M.A., Agafonova E.V., Viskontene A.L., Guseva N.V. & Natalyin N.A. 2022. [Species composition, abundance, and distribution of bats at hibernation sites in Leningrad Region in 2019–2021] // [Mammals in the changing world: actual problems of Theriology. Proceedings of the XI Congress of the Theriological Society of the Russian Academy of Sciences. March 14–18, 2022, Moscow, IEE RAS]. Moscow: KMK Scientific Press. P.224 [in Russian].
  • Matlova M.A., Degtyareva A.V., Krylova A.L., Rakitskaya T.A. & Agafonova E.V. 2020. [Some data on the water bat (Myotis daubentonii) wintering in the caves of the Leningrad Region for 2018–2020] // Plecotus et al. No.23. P.13–30 [in Russian, with English summary].
  • Meyer C.F.J. 2015. Methodological challenges in monitoring bat population- and assemblage-level changes for anthropogenic impact assessment // Mammalian Biology. Vol.80. No.3. P.159–169.
  • Nistreanu V., Caldari V., Larion A. & Dibolscaia N. 2022. Bat fauna (Mammalia: Chiroptera) from Saharna limestone mines, Republic of Moldova // Bulletin of the Academy of Sciences of Moldova. Life Sciences. Vol.2(346). P.64–71.
  • Novikov G.A., Airapetjantz A.E., Pukinsky Yu.B., Strelkov P.P. & Timofeeva E.K. 1970. [The Mammals of Leningrad Region (The Fauna, Ecology and Practical Importance)]. Leningrad: Leningrad State University. 360 p. [in Russian].
  • Orlov O.L. 2000. [Fauna and ecology of bats (Mammalia, Chiroptera) of the Middle Urals]. PhD Thesis in Biology. Yekaterinburg. 167 p. [in Russian].
  • Panteleikov M.A. 2016. [Prospects for the use of underground facilities of the Leningrad Region in ecological tourism]. Saint Petersburg: RSHU. 81 p. [in Russian].
  • Piksa K. & Nowak J. 2013. The bat fauna hibernating in the caves of the Polish Tatra Mountains, and its long-term changes // Central European Journal of Biology. Vol.8. No.5. P.448–460.
  • Reusch C., Scheuerlein A., Grosche L., Meier F., Gampe J., Dammhahn M., van Schaik J. & Kerth G. 2023. The risk faced by the early bat: individual plasticity and mortality costs of the timing of spring departure after hibernation // Oikos. No.4. P.e09654.
  • Siivonen Y. & Wermundsen T. 2008. Characteristics of winter roosts of bat species in southern Finland // Mammalia. Vol.72. P.50–56.
  • Smirnov D.G., Vekhnik V.P., Kurmaeva N.M., Shepelev A.A. & Il’in V. Yu. 2007. [Species structure and dynamics of bat communities (Chiroptera: Vespertilionidae) hibernating in artificial caves of Samara Luka] // Proceedings of the Academy of Sciences. Biological Series. Vol.34. No.5. P.608–618 [in Russian].
  • Smirnov D.G. & Vekhnik V.P. 2011. Abundance and community structure of bats (Chiroptera: Vespertilionidae) hibernating in artificial caves of Samarskaya Luka // Russian Journal of Ecology. Vol.42. No.1. P.71–79.
  • Smirnov D.G., Vekhnik V.P., Kurmaeva N.M. & Shepelev A.A. 2012. [Seasonal features of the spatial structure formation in bat colonies in the caves of Samarskaya Luka] // Povolzhskiy Journal of Ecology. No.1. P.73–82 [in Russian].
  • Smirnov D.G., Vekhnik V.P., Kurmaeva N.M., Bezrukov V.A., Baishev F.Z., Protasova O.V., Yalysheva E.G., Glukhova G.V., Dementieva A.V. & Evdokimova A.A. 2017. [Results of winter bat census (Chiroptera, Vespertilionidae) in the artificial caves of Samarskaya Luka in 2004–2016] // Novikova L.A. (ed.). [Natural heritage of Russia: scientific Art. Coll. of International scientific conf., dedicated to the 100th anniversary of the national nature reserve and the Year of Ecology in Russia (Penza, May 23–25, 2017). Penza: Penza State University. P.250–252 [in Russian].
  • Spitzenberger F. & Engelberger S. 2013. Negative trend reversal after 16 years of constant growth: The case of Rhinolophus hipposideros in an Austrian mass hibernaculum (Chiroptera: Rhinolophidae) // Lynx, n.s. (Praha). Vol.44. P.149–156.
  • Strelkov P.P. 1958. [Materials on the hibernation sites of bats in the European part of the USSR] // Trudy Zoologicheskogo Instituta AN SSSR. Vol.25. P.255–303 [in Russian].
  • Strelkov P.P. 1961. [Inhabitants of the artificial caves] // Priroda. Vol.1961. No.5. P.106–109 [in Russian].
  • Strelkov P.P. 1965. [Hibernation of bats (Chiroptera, Vespertilionidae) in the middle and northern part of the European USSR]. PhD thesis in Biology. Leningrad: ZIN AS USSR. 22 p. [in Russian].
  • Strelkov P.P. 1971. [Ecological observations of bats (Chiroptera, Vespertilionidae) hibernation in the Leningrad Region] // Trudy Zoologicheskogo Instituta AN SSSR. Vol.48. P.251–303 [in Russian].
  • Strelkov P.P. 1974. [Bat banding at hibernating sites] // [Proceedings of the First All-Union Meeting on Bats (Chiroptera)]. Leningrad: ZIN AS USSR. P.21–30 [in Russian].
  • Strelkov P.P. & Buntova E.G. 1982. [Whiskered bat (Myotis mystacinus) and Brandt’s bat (Myotis brandti) in the USSR, and the relationship of these species. Report 1] // Zoologicheskii Zhurnal. Vol.61. No.8. P.1227–1241 [in Russian, with English summary].
  • Strelkov P.P. & Buntova E.G. 1983. [Whiskered bat (Myotis mystacinus) and Brandt’s bat (Myotis brandti) in the USSR, and the relationship of these species. Report 2] // Zoologicheskii Zhurnal. Vol.62. No.2. P.259–270 [in Russian, with English summary].
  • Tidenberg E.-M., Liukko U.-M. & Stjernberg T. 2019. Atlas of Finnish bats // Annales Zoologici Fennici. Vol.56. No.1–6. P.207–250.
  • Uhrin M., Benda P., Obuch J. & Urban P. 2010. Changes in abundance of hibernating bats in central Slovakia (1992–2009) // Biologia. Vol.65. No.2. P.349–361.
  • Van der Meij T., Van Strien A.J., Haysom K.A., Dekker J., Russ J., Biala K., Bihari Z., Jansen E., Langton S., Kurali A., Limpens H., Meschede A., Petersons G., Presetnik P., Pruger J., Reiter G., Rodrigues L., Schorcht W., Uhrin M. & Vintulis V. 2015. Return of the bats? A prototype indicator of trends in European bat populations in underground hibernacula // Mammalian Biology. Vol.80. No.3. P.170–177.
  • Verhees J.J.F., Buys J.C., van Hoof P.H., Heijligers H.W.G. & de Boer W.F. 2022. Long-term trends of bats hibernating in small artificial hibernacula in northern Limburg and population dynamics explained by climatic conditions // Lutra. Vol.65. No.1. P.119–133.
  • Vintulis V. & Šuba J. 2010. Autumn swarming of the pond bat Myotis dasycneme at hibernation sites in Latvia // Estonian Journal of Ecology. Vol.59. No.1. P.70–80.
  • Vintulis V. & Petersons G. 2014. Root cellars are important winter roosts for brown long-eared bats (Plecotus auritus) and northern bats (Eptesicus nilssonii) in Latvia // Mammalia. Vol.78. No.1. P.85–91.
  • Vlaschenko A. & Naglov A. 2018. Results of the 10-year monitoring of bat (Chiroptera, Vespertilionidae) winter aggregation from the North-Eastern Ukraine (Liptsy Mines, Kharkiv Region) // Vestnik Zoologii. Vol.52. No.5. P.395–416.
  • Wegiel A., Grzywinski W., Kosicki J.Z., Tryjanowski P., Nowak J. & Wegiel J. 2021. Long-term population trends of Rhinolophus hipposideros and Myotis myotis in Poland // European Zoological Journal. Vol.88. No.1. P.1189–1200.
  • Wermundsen T. & Siivonen Y. 2010a. A comparison of the hibernation patterns of seven bat species in Estonia // Lutra. Vol.5. P.51–62.
  • Wermundsen T. & Siivonen Y. 2010b. Seasonal variation in use of winter roosts by five bat species in south-east Finland // Central European Journal of Biology. Vol.5. No.2. P.262–273.
  • Whiting-Fawcett F., Field K.A., Puechmaille S.J., Blomberg A.S. & Lilley T.M. 2021. Heterothermy and antifungal responses in bats // Current Opinion in Microbiology. Vol.64. P.61–67.
  • Zima J., Kovarik M., Gaisler J., Rehak Z. & Zukal J. 1994. Dynamics of the number of bats hibernating in the Moravian karst in 1983 to 1992 // Folia Zoologica. Vol.43. No.2. P.109–119.

Download PDF